Stock Market Sentiment: How to Read the Mood of the Market

Price tells you what the market did.

Sentiment tells you what the market feels.

And often, what the market feels is more predictive than what it just did.

When everyone is euphoric, markets tend to top. When everyone is terrified, markets tend to bottom. This isn't mysticism—it's the mechanics of supply and demand meeting human psychology.

Market sentiment is the collective mood of investors. Learn to read it, and you gain an edge that pure price analysis can't provide.

This guide breaks down what sentiment is, how to measure it, and how to use it in your trading.

What Is Market Sentiment?

Market sentiment is the overall attitude of investors toward the market or a specific security.

• Bullish sentiment: Investors are optimistic, expecting prices to rise
• Bearish sentiment: Investors are pessimistic, expecting prices to fall
• Neutral sentiment: No strong conviction either way

Sentiment isn't about what should happen based on fundamentals. It's about what investors believe will happen—and how they're positioned.

Why Sentiment Matters

Markets are not purely rational.

If they were, prices would always reflect fair value. Instead, markets swing from overvaluation (greed) to undervaluation (fear) and back again.

Sentiment helps explain:

• Why stocks fall on good earnings (expectations were too high)
• Why markets rally on bad news (pessimism was overdone)
• Why trends persist longer than fundamentals justify
• Why reversals happen suddenly

The Warren Buffett principle:

"Be fearful when others are greedy, and greedy when others are fearful."

This is sentiment trading in one sentence.

The Psychology Behind Sentiment

Market sentiment is driven by two primary emotions:

Fear

Fear dominates during:

• Market crashes and corrections
• Economic uncertainty
• Geopolitical crises
• Unexpected negative news

How fear manifests:

• Panic selling (regardless of fundamentals)
• Flight to safety (bonds, gold, cash)
• Increased hedging (put options, VIX spikes)
• Negative news gets amplified
• Positive news gets ignored

Extreme fear often signals:

• Short-term bottoms
• Buying opportunities for long-term investors
• Oversold conditions

Greed

Greed dominates during:

• Bull markets and rallies
• Economic expansion
• FOMO (fear of missing out)
• Speculative manias

How greed manifests:

• Buying regardless of valuation
• Chasing momentum and hot stocks
• Ignoring risk (no hedging)
• Positive news gets amplified
• Negative news gets dismissed

Extreme greed often signals:

• Short-term tops
• Time to reduce risk
• Overbought conditions

The Sentiment Cycle

Markets move through predictable emotional phases:

code-highlight
Optimism → Excitement → Thrill → Euphoria (TOP)
    ↓
Anxiety → Denial → Fear → Panic (BOTTOM)
    ↓
Capitulation → Despondency → Depression
    ↓
Hope → Relief → Optimism (cycle repeats)

The best buying opportunities come during capitulation and despondency. The best selling opportunities come during euphoria.

Key Sentiment Indicators

No single indicator captures sentiment perfectly. Smart traders watch several:

1. CNN Fear & Greed Index

What it is: A composite index measuring market emotion on a scale of 0-100.

Scale:

• 0-25: Extreme Fear
• 25-45: Fear
• 45-55: Neutral
• 55-75: Greed
• 75-100: Extreme Greed

Components:

1. Stock price momentum (S&P 500 vs. 125-day average)
2. Stock price strength (52-week highs vs. lows)
3. Stock price breadth (advancing vs. declining volume)
4. Put/call ratio (options sentiment)
5. Junk bond demand (risk appetite)
6. Market volatility (VIX)
7. Safe haven demand (stocks vs. bonds)

How to use it:

• Readings below 20: Consider buying (contrarian)
• Readings above 80: Consider reducing exposure
• Extreme readings rarely last more than a few weeks

Where to find it: CNN Fear & Greed Index

2. VIX (Volatility Index)

What it is: The "fear gauge" measuring expected S&P 500 volatility over the next 30 days.

Scale:

• Below 15: Low fear, complacency
• 15-20: Normal range
• 20-30: Elevated fear
• Above 30: High fear
• Above 40: Extreme fear (rare)

How to interpret:

How to use it:

• VIX spikes often mark short-term bottoms
• Sustained low VIX can precede volatility expansion
• Watch for VIX divergences from price

Trading insight: VIX above 30 with S&P 500 at support = potential bounce setup.

3. Put/Call Ratio

What it is: The ratio of put options traded to call options traded.

Calculation: Total Put Volume ÷ Total Call Volume

Interpretation:

• Below 0.7: Bullish sentiment (more calls than puts)
• 0.7-1.0: Neutral
• Above 1.0: Bearish sentiment (more puts than calls)
• Above 1.2: Extreme bearishness (contrarian bullish)

Types:

• Equity put/call: Individual stock options
• Index put/call: S&P 500, Nasdaq options
• Total put/call: All options combined

How to use it:

• High put/call (>1.0) often precedes rallies
• Low put/call (below 0.6) often precedes pullbacks
• Works best at extremes, not in normal range

4. AAII Investor Sentiment Survey

What it is: Weekly survey asking individual investors if they're bullish, bearish, or neutral on the next six months.

Historical averages:

• Bullish: 37.5%
• Neutral: 31.5%
• Bearish: 31%

Extreme readings:

• Bullish > 50%: Contrarian bearish signal
• Bearish > 50%: Contrarian bullish signal
• Bull-Bear Spread > +30: Caution warranted
• Bull-Bear Spread < -20: Opportunity possible

How to use it:

• Extreme pessimism in AAII has historically preceded rallies
• Extreme optimism has preceded corrections
• Most useful at extremes, not for week-to-week trading

Where to find it: AAII Sentiment Survey

5. Market Breadth Indicators

What they measure: How many stocks are participating in a move.

Key breadth indicators:

Advance/Decline Line:

• Tracks cumulative advancing stocks minus declining stocks
• Rising A/D line = healthy broad participation
• Falling A/D line during rally = warning sign (narrow leadership)

Percentage of Stocks Above Moving Averages:

• % above 50-day MA: Short-term breadth
• % above 200-day MA: Long-term breadth
• Above 70%: Overbought (but can stay overbought in bull markets)
• Below 30%: Oversold (potential bounce)

New Highs vs. New Lows:

• More new highs = bullish breadth
• More new lows = bearish breadth
• Divergence from index = warning sign

How to use it:

• Healthy rallies have broad participation (many stocks rising)
• Unhealthy rallies have narrow leadership (only a few stocks rising)
• Breadth divergences often precede reversals

6. Fund Flows

What it measures: Where money is moving—into or out of asset classes.

What to watch:

• Equity fund inflows/outflows
• Bond fund flows
• Money market fund levels
• ETF flows (SPY, QQQ, sector ETFs)

Interpretation:

• Heavy equity inflows at highs = potential top (everyone already bought)
• Heavy equity outflows at lows = potential bottom (capitulation)
• Money market spikes = fear (cash on sidelines)

Sources:

• ICI (Investment Company Institute)
• EPFR Global
• ETF flow data (etf.com)

7. Social Media & News Sentiment

What it measures: The tone of financial discussion online.

Tools:

• StockTwits sentiment (bullish/bearish tags)
• Twitter/X financial discussion
• Reddit (WallStreetBets, investing subs)
• News headline sentiment analysis

How to use it:

• Extreme social media bullishness can signal tops
• Extreme bearishness can signal bottoms
• Meme stock sentiment often leads price moves

Caution: Social media can be manipulated. Use as one input, not sole indicator.

How to Use Sentiment in Trading

Approach 1: Contrarian Trading

The principle: Do the opposite of the crowd at extremes.

When to be contrarian bullish:

• Fear & Greed Index below 20
• VIX above 30
• Put/call ratio above 1.2
• AAII bearish above 50%
• Headlines screaming "crash"

When to be contrarian bearish:

• Fear & Greed Index above 80
• VIX below 12
• Put/call ratio below 0.6
• AAII bullish above 55%
• Headlines screaming "new paradigm"

Important: Contrarian signals tell you when to look for opportunities, not when to blindly trade. Always confirm with price action.

Approach 2: Sentiment Confirmation

The principle: Use sentiment to confirm technical setups.

Example bullish setup:

1. Stock pulls back to support
2. Technical indicators oversold (RSI < 30)
3. Market sentiment in fear zone
4. → Higher probability bounce

Example bearish setup:

1. Stock rallies to resistance
2. Technical indicators overbought (RSI > 70)
3. Market sentiment in greed zone
4. → Higher probability pullback

Sentiment adds a "weight of evidence" layer to technical analysis.

Approach 3: Sentiment-Based Position Sizing

The principle: Adjust risk based on market mood.

When sentiment is fearful:

• Larger position sizes (better risk/reward)
• Longer holding periods
• Less hedging needed

When sentiment is greedy:

• Smaller position sizes (elevated risk)
• Tighter stops
• More hedging (consider puts)

Example:

• Your normal position is 5% of portfolio
• Fear & Greed at 15 → Size up to 7%
• Fear & Greed at 85 → Size down to 3%

Approach 4: Sentiment Divergences

The principle: Watch for sentiment and price going opposite directions.

Bearish divergence:

• Price making new highs
• Sentiment indicators weakening
• Example: S&P 500 new high, but Fear & Greed falling from 80 to 60
• Signal: Rally may be exhausting

Bullish divergence:

• Price making new lows
• Sentiment indicators improving
• Example: S&P 500 new low, but VIX failing to make new high
• Signal: Selling may be exhausting

Sentiment Indicators by Timeframe

Short-Term (Days to Weeks)

Best indicators:

• VIX (daily changes)
• Put/call ratio (daily)
• Fear & Greed Index (daily)
• Social media sentiment

Use for: Timing entries/exits, short-term trading

Medium-Term (Weeks to Months)

Best indicators:

• AAII survey (weekly)
• Fund flows (weekly)
• Market breadth (10-day averages)
• Margin debt levels

Use for: Swing trading, position adjustments

Long-Term (Months to Years)

Best indicators:

• Household equity allocation
• Shiller P/E (CAPE) vs. historical
• Magazine cover indicator (anecdotal)
• Buffett Indicator (market cap to GDP)

Use for: Strategic allocation, major cycle positioning

Building a Sentiment Dashboard

Track these indicators regularly:

Daily Check (2 minutes)

Weekly Check (5 minutes)

What Extreme Readings Look Like

"Extreme Fear" environment:

• Fear & Greed: Below 20
• VIX: Above 30
• Put/Call: Above 1.2
• AAII Bearish: Above 50%
• Headlines: Apocalyptic

"Extreme Greed" environment:

• Fear & Greed: Above 80
• VIX: Below 12
• Put/Call: Below 0.6
• AAII Bullish: Above 55%
• Headlines: Euphoric

Setting Sentiment Alerts

Don't check sentiment manually every day. Set alerts for extreme readings.

With StockAlarm:

1. VIX spike alert

   • "Alert me when VIX crosses above 30"
   • Signals fear spike, potential opportunity

2. VIX complacency alert

   • "Alert me when VIX drops below 12"
   • Signals complacency, potential caution

3. Market breadth alert

   • "Alert me when % of S&P 500 above 50 MA drops below 20%"
   • Signals oversold breadth

4. Index extreme move alert

   • "Alert me when S&P 500 drops 3%+ in one day"
   • Panic days often precede bounces

The workflow:

1. Alert fires on sentiment extreme
2. Check other sentiment indicators
3. If multiple confirm, look for technical setup
4. If setup exists, consider trading

Sentiment Traps to Avoid

Trap 1: Trading Every Extreme

Problem: Sentiment reaches "extreme fear" but market keeps falling.

Reality: Extreme can get more extreme. Markets can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.

Solution: Use sentiment as context, not trigger. Wait for price confirmation (e.g., higher low) before acting on sentiment extremes.

Trap 2: Ignoring Trend

Problem: Sentiment is fearful, so you buy. But you're buying into a downtrend.

Reality: "Catching falling knives" kills accounts. Fear can be justified.

Solution: In downtrends, wait for sentiment extreme PLUS trend reversal signal. Don't fight strong trends just because sentiment seems overdone.

Trap 3: Single Indicator Reliance

Problem: VIX spikes to 35, so you buy. Market drops another 15%.

Reality: No single indicator is reliable enough to trade alone.

Solution: Require multiple sentiment indicators to align before acting. VIX spike + Fear & Greed below 20 + Put/Call above 1.2 = stronger signal.

Trap 4: Confusing Sentiment with Fundamentals

Problem: "Everyone is bearish, so the market must be undervalued."

Reality: Sometimes bearishness is correct. Sentiment tells you about positioning, not value.

Solution: Sentiment extremes create opportunities to buy good stocks cheap or sell bad stocks dear. They don't magically make bad stocks good.

Trap 5: Recency Bias

Problem: Sentiment was extreme fear last week. Market bounced. Next extreme must bounce too.

Reality: Each situation is different. Context matters enormously.

Solution: Evaluate each sentiment extreme in its specific context. What's causing it? Is it similar to past extremes that reversed, or different?

Sentiment in Different Market Regimes

Bull Markets

• Sentiment stays elevated longer
• "Overbought" can persist for months
• Fear spikes are buying opportunities
• Greed spikes may just mean "less upside" not "reversal"

Adjustment: Be slower to turn bearish on greed readings in strong bull markets.

Bear Markets

• Sentiment stays depressed longer
• "Oversold" bounces fail frequently
• Greed spikes are selling opportunities
• Fear spikes may just mean "less downside" not "reversal"

Adjustment: Be slower to turn bullish on fear readings in bear markets. Wait for trend change confirmation.

Range-Bound Markets

• Sentiment oscillates more predictably
• Extremes more reliably mark range boundaries
• Contrarian signals work better

Adjustment: Sentiment indicators most useful in choppy, range-bound conditions.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is stock market sentiment?

Stock market sentiment is the overall attitude or mood of investors toward the market or a specific stock. It reflects whether investors are feeling bullish (optimistic, expecting prices to rise) or bearish (pessimistic, expecting prices to fall). Sentiment is driven by emotions like fear and greed, and often moves independently of fundamentals.

How do you measure market sentiment?

Market sentiment is measured through various indicators: the CNN Fear & Greed Index (0-100 scale), VIX volatility index (fear gauge), put/call ratio (options sentiment), AAII investor survey (bullish/bearish readings), advance/decline ratio (market breadth), and fund flow data (where money is moving). No single indicator is perfect—traders typically watch several.

What is the Fear and Greed Index?

The Fear and Greed Index is CNN's composite sentiment indicator that measures market emotion on a scale of 0 (extreme fear) to 100 (extreme greed). It combines seven factors: stock price momentum, stock price strength, stock price breadth, put/call ratio, junk bond demand, market volatility (VIX), and safe haven demand. Readings below 25 indicate extreme fear; above 75 indicate extreme greed.

Is market sentiment a good indicator?

Market sentiment is useful as a contrarian indicator and for timing. Extreme sentiment readings often precede reversals—extreme fear can signal buying opportunities, extreme greed can signal caution. However, sentiment can stay extreme longer than expected, so it works best combined with technical and fundamental analysis rather than traded in isolation.

What does bullish sentiment mean?

Bullish sentiment means investors are optimistic and expect prices to rise. Signs of bullish sentiment include: rising stock prices on high volume, low VIX readings, high Fear & Greed Index (above 60), more call options than puts being bought, positive fund flows into stocks, and surveys showing majority of investors are bullish.

How do you trade market sentiment?

Most successful traders use sentiment as a contrarian indicator: buy when others are fearful, sell when others are greedy. Watch for extreme readings (Fear & Greed below 25 or above 75), then look for technical confirmation before acting. Sentiment also helps with position sizing—reduce risk when sentiment is euphoric, increase exposure during panic.

The Bottom Line

Sentiment won't tell you exactly when to buy or sell.

But it will tell you when to pay attention.

Extreme fear says: "The crowd is panicking. Is there opportunity here?" Extreme greed says: "The crowd is euphoric. Is there danger here?"

The best traders don't follow the crowd—they watch the crowd. When everyone is leaning one way, they start looking the other direction.

Use sentiment as one tool in your toolkit:

• Combine with technical analysis for timing
• Combine with fundamental analysis for stock selection
• Use extremes for position sizing
• Never trade sentiment alone

The market is made of people. People have emotions. Emotions create opportunity.

Learn to read the mood, and you'll see opportunities others miss.

Related Articles

• What Does "Risk-Off" Mean? Understanding Market Sentiment Shifts
• Why Markets Move Before News Breaks
• 7 Forces That Move Stock Prices
• How Professional Traders Monitor Markets Without Watching All Day