Wall Street analysts spend their careers studying companies and issuing ratings. Their Buy, Hold, and Sell recommendations move stocks and shape investor sentiment.
But how much should you trust them? What do price targets really mean? And how do you separate useful insights from Wall Street noise?
This guide explains how analyst ratings work, what to look for, and how to use this information in your investment decisions.
What Are Analyst Ratings?
Analyst ratings are recommendations issued by professional securities analysts who work at investment banks, brokerages, and research firms.
What analysts do:
- Research companies in specific sectors (tech analyst, healthcare analyst, etc.)
- Build financial models projecting future earnings
- Meet with company management
- Issue reports with ratings and price targets
- Update ratings based on new information
The output:
- Rating: Buy, Hold, Sell (or variations)
- Price Target: Where they think the stock will be in 12 months
- Estimates: Projected EPS and revenue
- Research Reports: Detailed analysis supporting their view
The Rating Scale Explained
Different firms use different terminology, but ratings generally fall into these categories:
Standard Ratings
| Rating | Meaning | Expected Performance |
|---|---|---|
| Strong Buy | Highest conviction | Significantly beat market |
| Buy / Outperform | Positive outlook | Beat the market |
| Hold / Neutral | Average outlook | Match the market |
| Underperform | Negative outlook | Lag the market |
| Sell | Avoid | Significantly lag market |
Common Firm-Specific Terms
| Firm Style | Bullish | Neutral | Bearish |
|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional | Buy | Hold | Sell |
| Goldman Sachs | Buy | Neutral | Sell |
| Morgan Stanley | Overweight | Equal-Weight | Underweight |
| JP Morgan | Overweight | Neutral | Underweight |
| Bank of America | Buy | Neutral | Underperform |
What "Outperform" and "Underperform" Mean
These are relative ratings:
- Outperform: Stock should beat its benchmark (S&P 500 or sector)
- Underperform: Stock should lag its benchmark
A stock rated "Outperform" could still decline — just less than the market. This is important because many investors misread relative ratings as absolute predictions.
Understanding Price Targets
A price target is where the analyst believes the stock will trade in the next 12 months.
Key Price Target Metrics
| Metric | Description |
|---|---|
| Target High | Most optimistic analyst's target |
| Target Low | Most pessimistic analyst's target |
| Consensus Target | Average of all targets |
| Median Target | Middle target (less skewed by outliers) |
How to Interpret Price Targets
Example: AAPL Price Targets
code-highlightCurrent Price: $185 Target Low: $160 (-14%) Consensus: $210 (+14%) Target High: $250 (+35%)
What this tells you:
- Most analysts are bullish (consensus above current price)
- Wide range shows disagreement ($90 spread)
- Even bears only see 14% downside
- Bulls see 35% upside potential
Price Target vs Current Price
| Scenario | Implied View |
|---|---|
| Target >> Current | Bullish, expects significant upside |
| Target > Current | Moderately bullish |
| Target ≈ Current | Neutral, fairly valued |
| Target < Current | Bearish, expects decline |
Limitations of Price Targets
- They're often stale — Targets may be months old
- They follow price — Analysts often raise targets after rallies
- 12-month horizon — May not match your timeframe
- Precise numbers, imprecise reality — "$217 target" implies false precision
- Conflicts of interest — Investment banking relationships can bias targets
Best practice: Use price targets to gauge sentiment direction, not as literal predictions.
Consensus Estimates: EPS and Revenue
Beyond ratings, analysts project future earnings and revenue. The consensus estimate is the average of all analyst projections.
Why Consensus Matters
Stock prices often move based on whether companies beat or miss consensus estimates.
code-highlightEXAMPLE: Q4 Earnings Consensus EPS: $1.50 Actual EPS: $1.58 Result: "Beat by $0.08" or "Beat by 5%" Likely stock reaction: Positive
Types of Estimates
| Estimate | Description |
|---|---|
| EPS (Earnings Per Share) | Profit per share of stock |
| Revenue | Total sales |
| EBITDA | Operating earnings before accounting adjustments |
| Guidance | Company's own forecast (compared to estimates) |
Reading Estimate Trends
Watch how estimates change over time:
| Trend | Implication |
|---|---|
| Rising estimates | Analysts becoming more bullish |
| Falling estimates | Analysts cutting expectations |
| Stable estimates | Consistent outlook |
| Widely dispersed | High uncertainty |
Pro tip: A stock can beat lowered estimates and still drop if the "beat" was only possible because estimates fell so much.
Earnings Surprises: Beat or Miss History
A company's track record of beating or missing estimates reveals management's credibility and guidance style.
What to Look For
| Pattern | Interpretation |
|---|---|
| Consistent beats | Conservative guidance, management under-promises |
| Consistent misses | Execution problems or over-promising |
| Mixed results | Volatile business or unpredictable market |
| Big beats | Strong momentum, potentially sandbagging |
The "Whisper Number"
Sometimes there's an unofficial "whisper number" above consensus — what traders really expect based on options positioning and sentiment.
A company can beat consensus but miss the whisper number, causing the stock to drop on an apparent "beat."
Earnings Surprise Impact
The magnitude of the beat/miss matters:
| Surprise | Typical Reaction |
|---|---|
| Beat by 10%+ | Strong rally, potential upgrade cycle |
| Beat by 1-5% | Modest positive reaction |
| In-line | Muted, focus shifts to guidance |
| Miss by 1-5% | Modest selling |
| Miss by 10%+ | Sharp decline, potential downgrades |
Analyst Actions: Upgrades and Downgrades
When analysts change their ratings, it can move stocks significantly.
Types of Analyst Actions
| Action | Description | Typical Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Upgrade | Raised rating (e.g., Hold → Buy) | Positive |
| Downgrade | Lowered rating (e.g., Buy → Hold) | Negative |
| Initiation | New coverage begins | Varies |
| Reiterate | Maintains existing rating | Neutral |
| Price Target Raise | Higher target, same rating | Mildly positive |
| Price Target Cut | Lower target, same rating | Mildly negative |
Why Upgrades/Downgrades Move Stocks
- Information signal — Analyst has new insight
- Institutional flows — Funds may adjust positions based on ratings
- Momentum effect — Upgrades attract buyers, downgrades attract sellers
- Media coverage — Ratings changes get headlines
Double Upgrades and Downgrades
A double upgrade (Sell → Buy) or double downgrade (Buy → Sell) signals a major view change and typically has larger impact than single-step changes.
How Many Analysts Cover a Stock?
The number of analysts covering a stock matters:
| Coverage | Implication |
|---|---|
| 30+ analysts | Large cap, well-followed, hard to find edge |
| 10-30 analysts | Good coverage, reasonable liquidity |
| 5-10 analysts | Mid-cap, less efficient pricing |
| 1-5 analysts | Small cap, potentially overlooked |
| 0 analysts | No institutional coverage, highest risk |
Coverage Changes
- Analyst initiates coverage: Often bullish (they chose to cover)
- Analyst drops coverage: Could signal problems or just resource reallocation
The Bull/Bear Ratio
Looking at the distribution of ratings reveals sentiment:
Reading the Distribution
code-highlightEXAMPLE: Stock XYZ Strong Buy: 10 Buy: 15 Hold: 8 Sell: 2 Strong Sell: 0 Total: 35 analysts Bull ratio: 25/35 = 71% bullish
What Different Distributions Signal
| Distribution | Signal |
|---|---|
| Mostly Buys | Wall Street consensus is bullish |
| Mostly Holds | Uncertainty or fairly valued |
| Mostly Sells | Rare — most analysts avoid Sell ratings |
| Evenly split | Controversial stock, strong opinions both ways |
The Sell Rating Problem
Analysts rarely issue Sell ratings because:
- Investment banking conflicts (don't anger potential clients)
- Access concerns (companies may cut off bearish analysts)
- Career risk (being wrong on a Sell is more visible)
Reality: Only ~5% of ratings are Sell. This skews the average bullish.
When Analyst Ratings Work (and Don't)
Ratings Work Best When:
- Analyst has deep expertise — Industry specialist with track record
- Thesis is differentiated — Not just following consensus
- Timing is early — Before the move, not after
- Multiple analysts agree — Coordinated upgrades/downgrades
- Supported by estimate revisions — Numbers back up the rating
Ratings Work Poorly When:
- Following price — Upgrading after 50% rally
- Conflicts of interest — Investment banking relationships
- Stale research — Old rating on changed situation
- Consensus already priced in — Everyone already knows it's a Buy
- Macro-driven moves — Individual ratings don't matter in crashes/rallies
Contrarian Use of Analyst Ratings
Sometimes the best opportunities come from fading consensus:
Contrarian Signals
| Situation | Contrarian View |
|---|---|
| 100% Buy ratings | Everyone's already in, who's left to buy? |
| Mass downgrades after crash | Capitulation, potential bottom |
| Analyst drops coverage | Neglected stock, potential opportunity |
| Huge target raises after rally | Chasing performance, potential top |
The "Wall of Worry" Effect
Stocks can climb a "wall of worry" — rising despite skeptical analysts. Conversely, they can slide down a "slope of hope" — falling despite bullish ratings.
Key insight: Analyst sentiment is a data point, not a directive.
How to Use Analyst Data in Your Process
Step 1: Check the Consensus
Before any trade, know:
- What's the consensus rating?
- What's the average price target?
- Is sentiment bullish, bearish, or mixed?
Step 2: Read the Distribution
Look beyond the average:
- Are ratings tightly clustered or spread out?
- Any recent upgrades or downgrades?
- Who are the bulls and bears?
Step 3: Track Estimate Revisions
Watch the direction:
- Are estimates rising or falling?
- How has the company performed vs. estimates?
- What's the guidance trend?
Step 4: Consider the Source
Weight analysts differently:
- Track record on this stock?
- Sector expertise?
- Independence from banking conflicts?
Step 5: Combine with Your Analysis
Analyst ratings should confirm or challenge your own thesis:
- If you're bullish and analysts are bearish, why the disagreement?
- If everyone agrees, is the opportunity already gone?
Common Mistakes with Analyst Ratings
Mistake 1: Treating Ratings as Instructions
A Buy rating isn't a directive to buy. It's one analyst's opinion based on their models and assumptions.
Mistake 2: Ignoring the Price Target Timeframe
A $200 target means nothing if the stock is at $195 and your horizon is 2 weeks, not 12 months.
Mistake 3: Chasing Upgrades
By the time you read about an upgrade, institutional investors have often already acted.
Mistake 4: Ignoring Conflicts of Interest
If a bank's investment banking arm does business with a company, take their Buy ratings with skepticism.
Mistake 5: Anchoring to Price Targets
Don't hold a losing position just because "the target is $250." Targets change.
Setting Alerts for Analyst Activity
Stay informed without constantly checking:
Alert Ideas
Rating changes:
- Upgrade or downgrade alerts
- New coverage initiation
Price target changes:
- Target raised/lowered by 10%+
- Stock hits analyst target
Earnings-related:
- Estimate revision alerts
- Pre-earnings consensus changes
With Stock Alarm
Track analyst activity on your watchlist stocks:
- View ratings distribution at a glance
- See price target ranges vs. current price
- Monitor recent analyst actions
- Check earnings surprise history
Visit any stock's analyst page to see the full picture.
Quick Reference: Analyst Ratings Cheat Sheet
Rating Translations
| What They Say | What It Often Means |
|---|---|
| Strong Buy | Very bullish, high conviction |
| Buy / Outperform | Bullish, expects to beat market |
| Hold / Neutral | Not exciting, but not selling |
| Underperform | Cautious, expects to lag |
| Sell | Rare — genuinely bearish |
Red Flags
- Upgrade after 50%+ rally (chasing)
- 100% Buy ratings (over-consensus)
- Price target equals current price (no upside)
- Analyst works for company's investment bank (conflict)
Green Flags
- Upgrade on pullback (buying weakness)
- Estimate revisions support rating change
- Differentiated thesis (not just following crowd)
- Analyst has strong track record on stock
Frequently Asked Questions
What do analyst ratings like Buy, Hold, and Sell mean?
Buy means analysts expect the stock to outperform the market. Hold means they expect average performance. Sell means they expect underperformance. Many firms use Strong Buy for highest conviction and add Underperform as a softer sell rating. Ratings are relative to expected market returns, not absolute predictions.
How accurate are analyst price targets?
Studies show analyst price targets are hit about 50% of the time within their stated timeframe (usually 12 months). They're better at identifying direction than exact price levels. Price targets are most useful as a gauge of sentiment rather than precise predictions.
Should I buy a stock just because analysts rate it a Buy?
No. Analyst ratings should be one input among many. Consider that analysts have conflicts of interest, ratings often lag price moves, and consensus views are already priced in. Use ratings to understand Wall Street sentiment, but combine with your own analysis.
What is the consensus estimate?
The consensus estimate is the average of all analyst predictions for a metric like earnings per share (EPS) or revenue. When a company "beats estimates," they exceeded this consensus. The consensus is important because stock prices often move based on whether results beat or miss it.
Why do stock prices sometimes drop on a Buy rating?
Stocks can drop on Buy ratings if the price target is lowered, if the rating was already expected (sell the news), or if the market disagrees with the analyst's thesis. Also, an upgrade from Sell to Hold (still not a Buy) can disappoint investors hoping for better.
Related Articles
Continue your stock research education:
- Stock Valuation Guide — Master P/E, P/S, and other key valuation ratios
- How to Pick Stocks — Complete framework for stock selection
- Earnings Season Guide — Navigate quarterly earnings announcements
- Trading Risk Management — Protect your capital with proper position sizing
- How to Build a Watchlist — Track stocks for potential opportunities
Ready to never miss a market move?
Stock Alarm Pro sends instant alerts to your phone, email, and desktop. Unlimited alerts. No credit card required.
Start Free Trial