Dow Theory Explained: The Foundation of Technical Analysis

Every technical analyst, whether they know it or not, uses concepts that originated with Dow Theory. Developed over 100 years ago, this framework for understanding market trends remains the foundation upon which modern technical analysis is built.

This guide explains Dow Theory's principles, how to apply them to today's markets, and why they still work after more than a century.

What Is Dow Theory?

Dow Theory is a framework for analyzing market trends developed by Charles Dow, co-founder of Dow Jones & Company and the Wall Street Journal. Through a series of editorials in the late 1800s and early 1900s, Dow laid out principles for understanding how markets move.

The Origins

Charles Dow (1851-1902):

• Founded Dow Jones & Company in 1882
• Created the Wall Street Journal in 1889
• Developed the Dow Jones Industrial Average (1896)
• Developed the Dow Jones Transportation Average (originally Railroad Average, 1884)

Dow never formally compiled his ideas into a unified theory. After his death, William Hamilton, Robert Rhea, and others organized his editorials into what we now call "Dow Theory."

Why Dow Theory Matters

Dow Theory established concepts that traders use daily:

Nearly every technical indicator and chart pattern builds on these foundational ideas.

The Six Tenets of Dow Theory

Tenet 1: The Market Discounts Everything

The principle: Stock prices reflect all known information—economic data, earnings, news, and even future expectations. The collective actions of all market participants are embedded in price.

What it means for traders:

• Price action is the ultimate indicator
• Fundamental factors are already "priced in"
• Focus on what price is doing, not what it "should" do
• News that doesn't move markets was already expected

Modern application: This is the foundation of technical analysis. If you believe prices reflect all information, then studying price movements tells you what informed participants are doing.

code-highlight
All known information → Market participant actions → Price movement
                                                          ↓
                              Technical analysis studies this

Tenet 2: The Market Has Three Trends

Dow identified three simultaneous trend types operating at different timeframes:

Primary Trend (Major Trend):

• Duration: 1-3 years or more
• The main bull or bear market
• What long-term investors care about
• Cannot be manipulated

Secondary Trend (Intermediate Trend):

• Duration: 3 weeks to 3 months
• Corrections within the primary trend
• Typically retraces 33% to 66% of prior move
• Often confused for trend reversals

Minor Trend (Short-term Trend):

• Duration: Less than 3 weeks
• Day-to-day fluctuations
• Considered "noise" in Dow Theory
• Can be manipulated by large players

Visual representation:

code-highlight
Primary Trend (Bull Market)
     ╱╲      ╱╲      ╱╲
    ╱  ╲    ╱  ╲    ╱  ╲     ↗ Overall direction: Up
   ╱    ╲  ╱    ╲  ╱    ╲
  ╱      ╲╱      ╲╱      ╲
  │      │
  │      └── Secondary trends (corrections)
  └── Minor trends (daily noise within each wave)

Practical application:

Tenet 3: Primary Trends Have Three Phases

Both bull and bear markets unfold in three distinct psychological phases:

Bull Market Phases

Phase 1: Accumulation

• Occurs at market bottoms
• Smart money buys while sentiment is extremely negative
• News is still bad, public is selling
• Volume is low, prices base
• Most don't recognize the bottom

Phase 2: Public Participation

• The trend becomes obvious
• Prices rise rapidly on increasing volume
• Positive news confirms the uptrend
• Technical traders enter
• The longest and most profitable phase

Phase 3: Excess/Distribution

• Speculation runs rampant
• "Everyone" is bullish, even non-investors
• Smart money quietly sells to latecomers
• Volume is high but price gains slow
• Signs of exhaustion appear

code-highlight
Bull Market Phases:

Price
  │                           ┌─── Phase 3: Excess
  │                      ╱────┘    (Distribution)
  │                 ╱───╱
  │            ╱───╱
  │       ╱───╱ ← Phase 2: Public Participation
  │  ╱───╱
  │─╱ ← Phase 1: Accumulation
  └──────────────────────────────── Time

Bear Market Phases

Phase 1: Distribution

• Occurs at market tops
• Smart money sells while optimism peaks
• Prices begin to fall on increasing volume
• Rallies fail to make new highs
• Most still believe the bull market is intact

Phase 2: Public Participation (Panic)

• The downtrend becomes obvious
• Selling accelerates, prices fall rapidly
• Negative news dominates headlines
• Margin calls force more selling
• The longest and most damaging phase

Phase 3: Despair

• Selling exhausted, all bad news priced in
• Prices stabilize at depressed levels
• No one wants to buy
• Volume dries up
• Smart money begins accumulating again

Where are we now? Identifying the current phase helps set expectations:

• Phase 1 (accumulation/distribution): Prepare for trend change
• Phase 2: Trade with the trend aggressively
• Phase 3: Take profits, prepare for reversal

Tenet 4: The Averages Must Confirm Each Other

The principle: For a trend to be valid, both the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) and the Dow Jones Transportation Average (DJTA) must confirm by moving in the same direction.

The logic:

• Industrials make goods
• Transports ship goods
• If business is truly improving, both should rise
• Divergence suggests the trend is suspect

Confirmation examples:

code-highlight
BULLISH CONFIRMATION:
DJIA: ────────╱╲────╱╲────╱ New High ✓
DJTA: ────────╱╲────╱╲────╱ New High ✓
→ Bull market confirmed

BEARISH CONFIRMATION:
DJIA: ╲────╱╲────╱╲────╲ New Low ✓
DJTA: ╲────╱╲────╱╲────╲ New Low ✓
→ Bear market confirmed

NON-CONFIRMATION (Warning):
DJIA: ────────╱╲────╱╲────╱ New High ✓
DJTA: ────────╱╲────╱╲──── No New High ✗
→ Bull market suspect, potential reversal

Modern interpretation: While the Industrial/Transport relationship remains relevant, traders now apply this principle more broadly:

Practical use:

• Check if small caps confirm large cap moves
• Look for sector breadth (are most sectors rising?)
• Use advance/decline line for market breadth
• International markets confirming US trends

Tenet 5: Volume Confirms the Trend

The principle: Volume should increase in the direction of the primary trend.

In a bull market:

• Volume should increase on rallies
• Volume should decrease on pullbacks
• Rising prices on falling volume = warning sign

In a bear market:

• Volume should increase on declines
• Volume should decrease on bounces
• Falling prices on falling volume = potential base forming

Volume analysis examples:

code-highlight
HEALTHY BULL TREND:
Price:  ╱╲  ╱╲  ╱╲  ╱ (Higher highs, higher lows)
Volume: ██ █ ██ █ ███ (Heavier on up moves)

WEAKENING BULL TREND:
Price:  ╱╲  ╱╲  ╱╲  ╱ (Still rising)
Volume: ██ ██ █ █ █ (Decreasing on rallies)

HEALTHY BEAR TREND:
Price:  ╲╱╲  ╱╲  ╱╲ (Lower highs, lower lows)
Volume: ██ █ ██ █ ██ (Heavier on down moves)

Key volume signals:

See our volume analysis guide for detailed volume trading strategies.

Tenet 6: A Trend Continues Until Clear Reversal

The principle: Assume the current trend will continue until there is definitive evidence it has reversed. Don't anticipate reversals—wait for confirmation.

What constitutes reversal?

• Primary uptrend reversal: Lower high followed by lower low
• Primary downtrend reversal: Higher low followed by higher high
• Both averages should confirm the reversal

The challenge: Distinguishing between a secondary correction and a primary trend reversal is difficult in real-time. Many traders call reversals prematurely during normal corrections.

Trend reversal signals:

code-highlight
UPTREND REVERSAL:
        ╱╲ ← Lower high (first warning)
       ╱  ╲
      ╱    ╲
     ╱╲     ╲
    ╱  ╲     ╲ ← Breaks prior low (reversal confirmed)
   ╱    ╲─────╲

DOWNTREND REVERSAL:
   ╲
    ╲    ╱──── Higher high (reversal confirmed)
     ╲  ╱
      ╲╱ ← Higher low (first sign)
       ╲╱ ← Prior low held

Practical rules:

1. Never fight the primary trend
2. Use corrections to enter in trend direction
3. Wait for confirmation before calling reversals
4. Err on the side of the existing trend
5. "The trend is your friend until it ends"

Applying Dow Theory Today

Step 1: Identify the Primary Trend

Questions to ask:

• Is the market making higher highs and higher lows? (Bullish)
• Is the market making lower highs and lower lows? (Bearish)
• Are we in a range with no clear direction? (Consolidation)

Tools to help:

• Weekly or monthly charts for perspective
• Major moving averages (50-week, 200-day)
• Year-to-date performance of major indices

Step 2: Locate the Current Phase

Accumulation/Distribution signs:

• Sentiment extremely negative/positive
• Smart money positioning (13F filings, insider buying)
• Low/high volume, basing/topping patterns

Public participation signs:

• Clear trend obvious to all
• Media coverage increasing
• Volume expanding in trend direction

Excess/Despair signs:

• Extreme sentiment readings
• "This time is different" narratives
• Volume climaxes, exhaustion gaps

Step 3: Check for Confirmation

Modern confirmation checklist:

• Is DJTA confirming DJIA?
• Is Russell 2000 confirming S&P 500?
• Are advance/decline lines confirming index moves?
• Are multiple sectors participating?
• Is volume confirming price direction?

Non-confirmation warnings:

• Large caps rising, small caps lagging
• Few stocks driving index gains
• Volume drying up on rallies
• Defensive sectors outperforming in "bull market"

Step 4: Trade with the Trend

Based on Dow Theory analysis:

Step 5: Respect the Trend Until Reversal

Stay with the trend:

• Don't fight the primary direction
• Use secondary reactions to add to positions
• Only reverse when clear reversal is confirmed
• Both averages should confirm any trend change

Dow Theory Examples in History

2007-2009 Bear Market

Distribution phase (Oct 2007 - Mar 2008):

• DJIA made new high in October 2007
• DJTA failed to confirm (non-confirmation warning)
• Financials began breaking down
• Smart money distribution evident

Public participation (Sep 2008 - Mar 2009):

• Lehman Brothers collapse triggered panic
• Both averages confirming lower lows
• Volume surged on down days
• Widespread fear and forced selling

Despair/Accumulation (Mar 2009):

• Sentiment at extreme lows
• "Generational bottom" narratives
• Volume dried up
• Both averages formed higher lows

2020 COVID Crash and Recovery

Distribution (Feb 2020):

• Rapid shift from excess phase
• COVID concerns emerged
• Non-confirmation appeared briefly

Panic phase (Feb-Mar 2020):

• Fastest 30% decline in history
• Both averages confirming lower lows
• Extreme volume on down days

Accumulation (Mar 2020):

• Fed intervention massive
• Smart money buying panic
• Higher low formed quickly

Public participation (Apr 2020 - Dec 2021):

• Both averages confirming higher highs
• Volume strong on rallies
• Broad sector participation

2022 Bear Market

Distribution (Jan 2022):

• DJIA and DJTA diverged from Nasdaq
• Inflation concerns rising
• Growth stocks breaking down first

Public participation (2022):

• Fed hiking cycle confirmed bear
• Both averages confirming lower lows
• Volume heavy on down days

Signs to watch for accumulation:

• Sentiment reaching extremes
• Higher lows forming
• Non-confirmation of new lows

Limitations and Criticisms of Dow Theory

Delayed Signals

The problem: Dow Theory waits for confirmation, which means signals come after significant moves have occurred.

Example:

• Primary trend change might be confirmed only after 20-30% move
• Traders miss the first phase of new trends
• By the time trend is "confirmed," risk/reward may be poor

Mitigation:

• Use other tools for earlier entries
• Accept some uncertainty for better risk/reward
• Use Dow Theory for overall bias, not specific entries

Subjectivity in Interpretation

The problem: Practitioners often disagree on:

• When a trend has changed
• Whether a correction is secondary or primary reversal
• How much confirmation is "enough"

Example:

• One analyst sees a secondary correction
• Another sees beginning of new bear market
• Both cite Dow Theory principles

Mitigation:

• Establish objective rules in advance
• Use quantitative measures alongside judgment
• Wait for clear, unambiguous signals

Industrial/Transport Relationship Changed

The problem: The economy has evolved since Dow's time:

• Services dominate over manufacturing
• Tech companies don't ship physical goods
• Transports less representative of economy

Mitigation:

• Apply confirmation principle to modern sectors
• Use market breadth measures
• Check small caps vs large caps
• Look at global market confirmation

Short-Term Limitations

The problem: Dow Theory is designed for primary trends (months to years), not:

• Day trading
• Swing trading (weeks)
• Short-term options

Mitigation:

• Use Dow Theory for overall market bias
• Apply principles at shorter timeframes (with caution)
• Combine with other technical tools for entries

Dow Theory and Modern Technical Analysis

Concepts Dow Theory Pioneered

Combining Dow Theory with Modern Indicators

For trend identification:

• Dow Theory: Are we in a bull or bear market?
• Moving averages: Is price above or below 200 SMA?
• Confirmation: Do both agree?

For phase analysis:

• Dow Theory: Which phase are we in?
• Sentiment indicators: Confirm phase extremes
• Volume patterns: Confirm accumulation/distribution

For confirmation:

• Dow Theory: Are averages confirming?
• Advance/decline line: Market breadth
• Sector rotation: Leadership changes

For entries:

• Dow Theory: Sets directional bias
• RSI: Times entries within trend
• Support/resistance: Specific price levels

Building a Dow Theory Trading Framework

Daily Checklist

code-highlight
WEEKLY ANALYSIS:
□ Primary trend direction (bull/bear/neutral)
□ Current phase (accumulation/participation/excess)
□ DJIA and DJTA confirmation status
□ Volume trend (confirming or diverging)
□ Any reversal signals present?

TRADING IMPLICATIONS:
□ Bias for the week (long/short/neutral)
□ Position sizing based on phase
□ Key levels for the week
□ What would change my bias?

Position Sizing by Phase

Stop Loss Placement Using Dow Theory

For long positions in uptrend:

• Stop below the most recent higher low
• This preserves the trend structure
• If broken, trend may be reversing

For short positions in downtrend:

• Stop above the most recent lower high
• Preserves downtrend structure
• If broken, trend may be reversing

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Dow Theory?

Dow Theory is a framework for understanding market trends developed by Charles Dow in the late 1800s. It consists of six core tenets that explain how markets move, how trends develop in three phases, and how the Dow Jones Industrial and Transportation averages must confirm each other for a valid trend signal. It forms the foundation of modern technical analysis.

What are the three types of trends in Dow Theory?

Dow Theory identifies three types of trends: Primary trends (major bull or bear markets lasting 1-3 years), Secondary trends (corrections within the primary trend lasting weeks to months, typically retracing 33-66% of the prior move), and Minor trends (day-to-day fluctuations lasting less than three weeks that are considered noise).

What does it mean when the averages must confirm each other?

This Dow Theory principle states that for a trend to be valid, both the Dow Jones Industrial Average and the Dow Jones Transportation Average must move in the same direction and confirm new highs or lows together. If one average makes a new high but the other fails to confirm, it signals potential trend weakness or reversal.

Is Dow Theory still relevant today?

Yes, Dow Theory remains highly relevant. Its core principles—trends persist until reversed, volume confirms trends, and major indices should confirm—are foundational to technical analysis. While markets have evolved, human psychology driving price movements hasn't changed. Many traders use Dow Theory alongside modern indicators for trend confirmation.

What are the three phases of a primary bull market?

According to Dow Theory, a bull market has three phases: Accumulation (smart money buys while sentiment is negative), Public Participation (the majority recognizes the trend and prices rise rapidly), and Excess/Distribution (speculation peaks, smart money sells to latecomers, and the trend nears exhaustion).

Related Articles

• How to Read Stock Charts - Chart reading fundamentals
• Technical vs Fundamental Analysis - Comparing approaches
• Market Cycles Guide - Bull and bear market phases
• Volume Analysis Guide - Confirming trends with volume
• Moving Averages Explained - Modern trend identification
• RSI Indicator Guide - Timing within trends
• Sector Rotation Strategies - Sector confirmation