SA
education

SCHD vs VOO: What 14 Years of Real Returns and Dividends Show

SCHD vs VOO, measured on real fund data. From 2012 through 2025, $10,000 in VOO grew to about $70,200 and $10,000 in SCHD to about $48,500, while SCHD paid about 60% more in dividends. See returns by year, income, overlap, declines, and how to choose.

Stock Alarm Team
Market Analysis
15 min read
#SCHD vs VOO#dividend etf#s&p 500#dividend investing#etf comparison#etf alerts

VOO is the default choice for owning the US stock market. SCHD is the most popular dividend fund in America. Investors compare them constantly, and they are far less alike than most index fund pairs.


"SCHD or VOO?" is really a question about what you want from your money: the most growth, or a larger and faster-growing stream of cash along the way.

This guide measures the trade-off with real numbers. We compared both funds over every full calendar year since SCHD launched, 2012 through 2025, using dividend-adjusted prices and each fund's actual dividend payments. Then we looked at what each fund holds today, how much they overlap, how far each has fallen in bad markets, and what that means for choosing.

The Short Answer

SCHDVOO
Index trackedDow Jones U.S. Dividend 100S&P 500
Number of holdingsabout 100about 500
Expense ratio0.06%0.03%
Dividend yield, past 12 months3.1%1.2%
Technology weighting16.2%38.3%
Ten largest holdings, share of fund42%37%
Compound return, end of 2011 to 202511.9% a year14.9% a year
$10,000 invested at the end of 2011about $48,500about $70,200
Calendar years ahead (2012-2025)410
Dividend growth per share, 2012 to 202511.5% a year7.3% a year
Worst decline since 2012-33.4%-34.0%

Source: FMP fund data as of November 22, 2026, FMP dividend history, and FMP end-of-day dividend-adjusted prices through November 20, 2026. Returns include reinvested dividends and are before taxes.

In plain terms: VOO made more money over the full period. SCHD paid more cash every single year, raised that cash faster, and fell clearly less in three of the last four market declines. Neither result is guaranteed to repeat.

Loading chart…

What Each Fund Actually Owns

VOO is the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF. It holds about 500 large US companies and weights them by size, so the biggest companies get the most money. It launched in September 2010.

SCHD is the Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF. It launched in October 2011 and tracks the Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 Index. That index starts with companies that have paid dividends for at least ten years in a row, then ranks them on measures of financial strength and dividend quality, such as cash flow compared with debt, return on equity, dividend yield, and dividend growth. The top 100 make the fund. Position sizes are capped, so no single company dominates.

Those two sets of rules produce very different portfolios:

SectorSCHDVOO
Consumer defensive19.8%4.9%
Healthcare18.7%10.3%
Energy16.4%3.9%
Technology16.2%38.3%
Financial services8.8%12.0%
Industrials7.7%7.6%
Consumer cyclical6.8%9.2%
Communication services5.5%8.4%
Utilities0.1%2.1%
Real estate0%1.8%
Basic materials0%1.6%

Source: FMP fund data, November 22, 2026. Weightings change over time.

VOO has more than twice as much in technology. SCHD has about four times as much in consumer staples and energy. These are the sectors that tend to pay steady dividends: household products, soft drinks, drug makers, oil producers.

Here are the five largest positions in each fund:

SCHDWeightVOOWeight
PG4.6%AAPL7.7%
TXN4.6%NVDA7.6%
KO4.4%MSFT5.9%
HD4.3%AMZN3.6%
AMGN4.0%GOOGL2.5%

Source: FMP fund holdings, November 22, 2026.

How Much Do SCHD and VOO Overlap?

Very little, once you measure by dollars.

As of November 22, 2026:

  • About 95% of SCHD's money is in companies that are also in the S&P 500. Almost everything SCHD owns, VOO owns too.
  • But those same companies add up to only about 8% of VOO. The other 92% of VOO is in companies SCHD does not hold.
  • None of VOO's ten largest holdings is in SCHD. The biggest names in VOO pay small dividends or none, so they do not pass SCHD's rules.
  • SCHD's largest position, PG, is 4.6% of SCHD and about 0.6% of VOO.

What this means for you: this is a real choice, unlike VOO versus VTI, where 89% of the money is the same. SCHD and VOO can and do go in different directions for years at a time. That is also why some investors hold both. Our Magnificent 7 guide covers the group of very large companies that drives VOO and is missing from SCHD.

SCHD vs VOO Returns by Year, 2012-2025

Here is every full calendar year since SCHD launched, with dividends reinvested:

YearSCHDVOOAhead
2012+11.1%+16.0%VOO by 4.9
2013+32.8%+32.4%SCHD by 0.4
2014+11.4%+13.5%VOO by 2.1
2015-0.4%+1.3%VOO by 1.8
2016+16.2%+12.2%SCHD by 4.0
2017+20.8%+21.8%VOO by 1.0
2018-5.6%-4.5%VOO by 1.1
2019+27.3%+31.4%VOO by 4.1
2020+15.0%+18.3%VOO by 3.3
2021+29.8%+28.8%SCHD by 1.0
2022-3.3%-18.2%SCHD by 14.9
2023+4.5%+26.3%VOO by 21.8
2024+11.7%+25.0%VOO by 13.3
2025+4.3%+17.8%VOO by 13.5

Source: FMP end-of-day dividend-adjusted closes, last trading day of each year. The "Ahead" column is in percentage points and was calculated before rounding, so it can differ by 0.1 from the rounded figures beside it.

Three things stand out:

  1. For the first ten years, the gap was modest. From 2012 through 2021 the two funds were never more than five percentage points apart in any year.
  2. Then they split. In 2022, when technology stocks fell hard, SCHD lost 3.3% and VOO lost 18.2%. Over the next three years VOO beat SCHD by 13 points or more every year, as the largest technology companies led the market.
  3. VOO was ahead more often, in 10 of 14 years.

2026 so far

The pattern has reversed again. Through November 20, 2026, SCHD is up 26.8% for the year and VOO is up 2.2%. That is the largest gap in SCHD's favor since the fund launched, and it is not a full calendar year yet, so it is not in the table above.

Including 2026 to date, $10,000 invested at the end of 2011 is worth about $61,500 in SCHD and about $71,800 in VOO. Eleven months erased more than half of a gap that took three years to build.

The Start Date Changes the Story

PeriodSCHDVOO
End of 2011 to 2025 (14 years)11.9% a year14.9% a year
End of 2011 to 2020 (9 years)13.7% a year15.2% a year
End of 2020 to 2025 (5 years)8.9% a year14.4% a year
End of 2022 to 2025 (3 years)6.8% a year23.0% a year

Source: FMP end-of-day dividend-adjusted closes.

Most "VOO crushed SCHD" charts are really charts of 2023 through 2025. In those three years VOO returned 23.0% a year and SCHD 6.8%. That stretch accounts for most of the 14-year gap.

It works the other way too. Anyone who looks only at 2022, or only at 2026 so far, will conclude that SCHD is the better fund. Neither short window tells you what the next one will look like. What the full record does show is that VOO's return depends heavily on large technology companies, and SCHD's does not. Our guide to growth stocks versus value stocks explains why the two styles take turns leading.

The Dividend Side: Where SCHD Leads

Total return is only half of this comparison. The reason people buy SCHD is the income.

Suppose you put $10,000 into each fund at the end of 2011, never added a dollar, and took every dividend as cash instead of reinvesting it. Here is what each fund paid you:

YearSCHD dividendsVOO dividends
2012$292$247
2014$389$304
2016$456$360
2018$550$412
2020$775$462
2022$978$518
2024$1,139$583
2025$1,200$615

Source: FMP dividend history, adjusted for share splits, applied to the number of shares $10,000 bought at the December 30, 2011 close.

By 2025, the SCHD holding was paying about $1,200 a year, which is 12% of the original $10,000. The VOO holding was paying about $615, or 6.2%.

A few more measurements:

  • SCHD paid more in every one of the 14 years.
  • SCHD's dividend grew faster. Its dividend per share rose from about $0.25 in 2012 to about $1.05 in 2025, a compound 11.5% a year. VOO's rose from $2.84 to $7.07, or 7.3% a year.
  • Total cash collected over 14 years: about $9,560 from SCHD and about $6,000 from VOO.
  • VOO cut its payout once. VOO's dividends per share fell about 5% in 2020. SCHD's rose about 18% that year.

Now the other side of the ledger. At the end of 2025, the SCHD shares in this example were worth about $31,400. The VOO shares were worth about $54,600.

No reinvestment, end of 2011 to 2025SCHDVOO
Dividends collected$9,560$6,000
Value of the shares at the end$31,400$54,600
Total$41,000$60,600

What this means for you: SCHD paid about 60% more cash, and VOO still ended up with about $19,600 more in total. A higher yield did not mean a higher return. It meant more of the return arrived as cash. Whether that matters depends on whether you need the cash. See dividend yield explained and our guide to total return investing.

Which Fund Falls More in a Bad Market?

VOO, in each of the last four declines, though not always by much:

DeclineSCHDVOO
Late 2018-17.1%-19.5%
Pandemic, early 2020-33.4%-34.0%
2022-16.8%-24.5%
Early 2025-14.0%-18.7%

Source: FMP end-of-day dividend-adjusted closes, each fund measured from its own peak to its own low.

In 2022 and 2025, the selling was concentrated in technology and other fast-growing companies, and SCHD held up much better. In 2020, investors sold nearly everything at once, including energy companies and banks, and SCHD offered almost no protection.

Day to day, SCHD is a little calmer. Across about 3,700 trading days from 2012 through November 20, 2026:

  • VOO fell 2% or more on 108 days. On those days VOO lost an average of 3.1% and SCHD an average of 2.5%.
  • SCHD fell less than VOO on 91 of those 108 days.
  • The correlation between their daily returns was 0.87. For comparison, VOO and VTI are above 0.99.

SCHD is a lower-volatility stock fund. It is not a safe asset. It has lost a third of its value before. Our guide to max drawdown explains how to read decline figures like these.

Can You Hold Both?

Yes, and unlike most index fund pairs, it changes what you own.

Because only about 8% of VOO is in SCHD's holdings, mixing the two gives you a portfolio that differs from either one. A half-and-half split, using today's figures, would have about 27% in technology instead of VOO's 38%, and a dividend yield of about 2.1% instead of VOO's 1.2%.

The cost of that mix is the same one shown above. In years when the largest technology companies lead, the SCHD half will hold you back. In years like 2022 or 2026 so far, it will carry you.

How to Choose

VOO may fit better if:

  • You are years away from needing income and want the broadest ownership of large US companies.
  • You want to match the S&P 500, the benchmark most funds and most news reports are measured against.
  • You hold the fund in a taxable account and would rather not receive a larger dividend each quarter. Dividends are generally taxed in the year you receive them, even if you reinvest. See our capital gains tax guide.

SCHD may fit better if:

  • You want cash income now, or soon, without selling shares.
  • You want less of your portfolio riding on a handful of very large technology companies.
  • A rising dividend check helps you stay invested when prices fall. That behavior is worth more than most people expect.

Things that should not decide it:

  • Fees. SCHD charges 0.06% a year and VOO 0.03%. On $10,000 that is $6 versus $3. See ETF expense ratios explained.
  • Share price. SCHD trades near $34 and VOO near $636. That says nothing about value. SCHD split its shares three-for-one in October 2024, which lowered the price without changing what holders owned.
  • Yield alone. As the table above shows, the fund with the higher yield produced the lower total over 14 years.
  • The most recent year. In 2025 that pointed to VOO. In 2026 so far it points to SCHD.

Using Stock Alarm to Hold Either Fund

Long-term fund investors do not need to watch prices every day. A few alerts can do the watching:

  1. Set drawdown alerts on each fund you own. For example, a price alert 10% and 20% below the recent high. Because SCHD and VOO fall by different amounts at different times, set them separately. When one fires, follow the plan you already made, such as adding money or rebalancing. Our guide to setting stock price alerts explains how to choose levels.
  2. Add a large daily move alert. VOO has fallen 2% or more on only 108 days in 14 years. A percentage-change alert at that level tells you when something unusual is happening, so quiet days can stay quiet.
  3. Watch the long-term trend. An alert when a fund crosses its 200-day moving average gives you one clear signal about the bigger picture. See how to use moving averages.
  4. If you hold both, watch the gap. The two funds were 13 or more points apart in each of the last four full years. A large gap is a natural time to check whether your mix has drifted from your target. See our portfolio rebalancing guide.
  5. Know the dividend dates. Both funds pay quarterly. Our guide to the ex-dividend date explains which day you must own shares by to receive a payment.

For more, see ETF alerts and stock alerts for long-term investors.

Bottom Line

From 2012 through 2025, VOO returned a compound 14.9% a year and SCHD 11.9%, turning $10,000 into about $70,200 and $48,500. Most of that gap opened in 2023 through 2025, and more than half of it has closed in 2026 so far.

SCHD's case is income and a smoother ride. It paid more cash in every year measured, grew its dividend 11.5% a year, and fell clearly less in three of the last four declines. VOO's case is growth: more total money, driven by large technology companies that SCHD does not own.

They are different enough that this is a real decision, and different enough that owning both is reasonable. Decide whether you need growth, income, or a mix, then hold through the years when your choice is behind. Each fund has had several.

This article is educational and not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results. SCHD and VOO are used here as widely held funds for measurement purposes, not as recommendations. Tax rules depend on your situation.

Stock Alarm on your phone

Set price alerts and follow the stocks you track in the Stock Alarm app for iPhone and Android.

Want alerts like these? Get started free.

Join 295,000+ traders using Stock Alarm to stay ahead of the market.

Track SCHD in real time

See SCHD's live price and charts free. Set a price alert so you never miss a move — it takes a free account, no card required. Trusted by 295,000+ investors.

S&P 500 Screener

Filter by metrics, fundamentals

Price Alerts

Never miss a move

35+ Global Markets

Stocks, crypto, futures

AI Analysis

Ask questions, get answers

Track SCHD — set an alert
Stock Alarm Pro Terminal

Live Terminal Charts, Multiples & Screeners for This Guide

Set Custom Price & Technical Alerts →
Data is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Past performance is not indicative of future results.